Sounds like one of the Yipe! games (I, II or III).
http://www.yipesoftware.com/index.htm
http://www.yipesoftware.com/yipeii.htm
http://www.yipesoftware.com/yipeiii_screens.html
Doesn't seem to be any screens of the first game...I guess I should add them to Mobygames. So lazy....