«

Is one of the big questions in philosophy

So what is the answer?

Is "I" the body or the Spirit? Or maybe both?

Here is an example that a philosopher made (don't remember his name)

"Mr.A and Mr. B are voluanteers in a test. They go into a machine and exchange "brains". So when Mr.A comes out he has the memories and thoughs, act and everything that is inside you (spiritual, not organic) of Mr. B and vice versa. So, is Mr. A still Mr. A or is He Mr.B now?"

When you have thought about that here's the next part.

"Mr. A has to choose a destiny for him when he comes out of the machine. The decision has to be COMPLETELY NOT-selfish. He has to say, which one will be tortured slowly and painfully to death, and which one of them will get one million dollars(Tax free :P). So if the decision has to be completely UN-selfish which one will get the million? Mr.A or Mr.B?"

Now, if you can reach a decision, all together, you have done something that philosophists haven't done, and probarbly never will.

[Havell]

I don't know about the first one but the second one is impossible because if Mr. A choose for himself to be tortured then he would have the charitable satisfaction of being kind to Mr. B so it would be selfish and if he choose to take the money then he would obviously be being selfish.

Well...If he wouldnt know what the Machine does, what then...What would he choose?

[Havell]

Which machine? The brain-swapping machine or the torture machine?

Brain swapping

[Puffin]

So THIS is what you were writing while I was baking the pizza... 8)

Not that we know each other, of course....
As far as this thingy you're talking about... I have NO idea....

[Havell]

With the first one, neither man would be one of the original men. Say if Mr. A is a contortionist and Mr. B is a weightlifter then swapping bodies would make both of them incapable of their jobs, Mr. A's consiousness would not be able to fit into small boxes etc. with Mr. B bulky body and Mr. B's consiousness would not be able to lift heavy weights with Mr. A's weedy body.

So you say they're not the same persons after the swap?

[Havell]

No, they would be Mr. C and Mr. D.

[Tom Henrik]

I agree. If you take one part of something (in this case the memories of a human) and combine this with something else (the body of another human, you would get something completely different. The two would interact in ways no one can imagine and create something new.