Well, there are situations where it's simple like that everyone has their own preferences.
On the other hand, if you see someone praising a backwards, under-developed, under-tested under-optimized piece of crap... well, it's obvious that one of three scenarios applies: a) he hasn't played much games so far or was sitting under a rock for several years of game releases, b) he's a fanboy or c) he really doesn't have any taste whatsoever.