[Oddbrother]

• I believe this game had the word 'Arena' in the title.
• It's a DOS game.
• Fantasy setting.
• Unlike Gladiator, this game is turn-based.
• Year unknown, possibly early 90s.
• Each player controls a mage, who can cast an array of spells and summon creatures.
• The title screen had an animated logo, and the main menu's background was just a jumbled mess of characters on a flat plain underneath a starry sky.
• Your cursor was a wire-drawn star (like a pentagram) that changed colors and left a short trail with every move you make.
• With the death of each mage, you get a message of the player's passing, followed by a written '*sniffle*'.
• I don't know if what I played was a demo or a full version, but at the end of each match, there was an image of a skull with red glow in its eye sockets. I don't know if it was to tease about the full version or just to tell the player that they lost.
• The graphics weren't really that pretty at the time. I think it was limited to a certain amount of colors, too. The game did play at a pretty decent screen resolution, though: 640 or higher.
• One of the mage's powers is "...to call something", which summons an indescribable creature at their command.
• They can also shoot fireballs and arrows.
• It was hosted on America Online's games service. So yes, in my eyes, it was an indie game.
• I think the mages can die in-game of old age, too.