I'm personally not too concerned whether a magazine or site rates everything above 50% or not, because it's relatively easy to skew that by focusing these days on only Big Name Titles from Big Name Companies that are done with reasonable (if sometimes very dull, ie, Rise of Nations) competence.
That said, if any game magazine reviews Dungeon Lords in its 1.0 state and gives it above 65%, I would be inclined to wave my privates in its aunties' faces.
