I guess I'm no expert on all the games, but I've noticed that not a single game on the site has received a 5 rating from members (all the great games are rated 4). Whilst loads of games have been rated 5 by whoever wrote the review.

This means that it is hard to differentiate what the members feel are "good" games from the "great games".

I assmue that if just some of the votes are not 5, then the game will not get a 5.

So could we change the criteria on the average for the games so that 4.5 rating or above is rated as a 5?

http://www.abandonia.com/forum/index.php?s...=3723&hl=rating


And as u can c majority voted its fine as it is so its fine as it is....

But u do make a valid point....i am for adding 4.5 grade but can u add 4.5 without adding .5 1.5 2.5 3.5???? i dont think so........

Adding x.5 would be exactly the same as doing a 1-10 scale.

1-5 has 5 steps
1-10 has 10 steps
1.0, 1,5, 2,0, 2,5 and so on - 5.0 has 10 steps = 1-10 = voted no

Closing down.

(don't take this personal Hkizzle, but it has been debated recently, you just missed out on it)