I cant seem to find a pirate game that doesnt have something wrong with it :(. Pirates! Gold is the closest but that thing is way to short :(. Anyone know any good ones?

Pirates! Gold is only as short as you make it, I've had really long games before, just select proficency at medicine as your skill anddon't retire :D

You could try the Uncharted Waters series.

Well, you could try Sea Dogs or Pirates of the Carribean LOL

You all forgot the original Pirates!-Ega version for PC.
Its better than Pirates! Gold,because it doesnt have any crappy graphics. :tomato:

http://www.burningsea.com/index.php

i think monkey island is a great game with pirates. altough it's a adventure with no RPG elements. but swordfighting is cool. :ok:

Not the new Pirates of teh caribean!!! Bought that...what a waste, pretty much no fun at all, stupid AI (got stuck behind an NPC in a cave...so I couldn't continue in the game any more at all) and there are tons of graphics bugs, particularily with the shipe, like he said try Monkey Island, not dl-able, but it sells pretty cheap now anyways.

Actually, there is a pretty big mod community dedicated to PoTC and they already have released a huge collection of small mods which improve, fix and extend the game in quite of ways, making it actually really fun.

Check piratesahoy.net if you're interested...definitely worth a try, of course it won't change the overall game mechanics so if you didn't like them this won't help either.

Do you know Corsairs and Corsairs II? I think that's the name in English, because I only played the Portuguese version.