The history of nations is always complicated. One thing for sure, no nation is a saint. But I just wonder, if there are so many rumors about that horrible Jewish fate in Poland, does anyone bring the question why there were so many Jews here in the first place? Say, maybe it's because they fled here fearful of religious persecutions in Western Europe (remember the Spanish Inquisition joke from Monthy Python?) and that Poland (the Commonwealth, to be more precise) was quite tolerant (at least if we compare it to the rest of the world, we never had, say, catholics vs. protestant massacres like in some other rich and developed countries, ahem) as we had laws agains religious oppresions?
Does anyone mention what other country in Europe had Jewish cinema industry making movies in Yiddish? Want to see some bilingual Yiddish-Polish posters? I can dig up a whole movie, too. And this goes only for orthodox Jews who didn't assimilate well. As others were famous artists here directing, writing popular songs etc. and their contribution here in not unlike of what their brethren did in Hollywood. Want me to sing you a few songs written by
Polish Jewish composers? I know many of them by heart.
I'm not saying that they had heaven on earth here. No orthodox ethnic minority sticking to own religion may consider itself "at home" - remember the US backlash against own Muslims after 9/11? But just comparing Poland to what happened in Germany is ridiculously unjust. We had anti-Jewish parties and sentiments and religious bigots like every other country with Jewish minority, but we never had state-run oppression machine like Nazi Germany had. We're portrayed very unfairly. It's either hysterical anti-Polish sentiment or anti-Jewish one. And media only love to throw more fuel to this fire.
Why modern Jews switched from blaming German Nazis to right-wing-extremist Poles, is it a new fad? Suddenly they forgot pogroms in Russia, both tzarist ("Fiddler on the Roof" anyone?) and Soviet? Oh, maybe because Russia still has nukes and gives a damn about accusations from its history as it can freely resort to economic blackmail? "Katyn massacre in 1940? How about we shut down your gas delivery in 2010, Polyatchki?"
Why mister Spielberg didn't care to make a movie about Irena Sendler, who saved approx. 1000 Jewish kids during WW2? And she had no business in that, unlike Schindler who was living off the slave Jewish workforce.
Right now I'm watching a charming movie from 1930s with my fav actress and a handsome Polish Clark Gable-lookalike. That guy was killed by Nazis in Auschwitz for making fake passports for Jews in the getto. Where are you, modern moviemakers?
They love to pick singular cases of Polish violence against Jews during the war. Do they also analyze where may it stem from? Do they show statistics that there was a large influx of Jews in communistic organizations, both pre war and during it (remember that political commisar from "Enemy at the gates"?) ? Jews were flocking to Soviet organizations like NKVD, what usually ended up in Polish families being arrested, shot or "only" deported to Siberia. Nobody mentions Jews sending Poles to death?
So yes, it is complicated.
|