Im with you and Littlefish. That would work best.
I cant wait to see it in action

like i said, one month add between 20-30 games since the site began, so the games are putted in one poll, and the winner add a review on sunday. If you want to go more deep in all months you can seperated by catergories, but in that case i don´t agree, because the number of games to poll in every week, it is very little and some games are unique in one month, so for me it was to putting all the games of the month to evry one wo want to poll. :D

Seb, when I meant cycle back through the catergories, I meant in a way so things wouldn't repeat. Meaning, that previous game would be void from the ballot.

I also think it would be a better idea to have each game open to votes, at least initially. By having admins choose 5 games or so for the members to vote on, that really limits the choices to what the ADMINS think are good. This is why I like my original idea, which would go something like this.

Monday: Updater's select the catergory for the week and announce it on the site. Forum members PM their votes to the updater in charge for the week on ANY game from the selected catergory.

Tuesday: Votes continue to be PM'ed

Wednesday: More votes...

Thursday: Open voting closed. Top 5-10 titles w/ most votes are selected and posted as a poll in the aforementioned topic. Board members vote on these 5-10 titles.

Friday-Saturday: More voting

Sunday: Voting closed, game of the week posted, new catergory is selected by next updater responsible for that week, process repeats itself.

Catergories can be something general, such as "Action", or it can be specific like "Sim Game," it's up to the updater to decide.