User Comments?

[Omuletzu]

A similar concept to that which is applied by HotU, and by many sites
It doesn't matter much for me, because as you all now, i don't read reviews(except for mine :tomato: ).This could help unsure people about dl a game or not

[Eagle of Fire]

It may be some strange thinking from me, but aren't the reviews user commented? ;)

[Omuletzu]

I mean things like
Add a comment, so every1 who wants to dl a game can read your comment BESIDES the review.
Just a thought though :whistle:

[Kon-Tiki]

Like when you think the review's unfair towards the game, or giving it too much credit. Then again, that's what the voting's for (even though there's the regular bozo who chooses 1 no matter the quality of the game)

[Wael]

But then there´s the fear of

"W00ts" "Game roxs" Da Gam de bests" etc etc...

[Omuletzu]

The same risk you take with the marking system.Many people just vote 1 or 5 regardless of the game value :ph34r: :tomato:

[Wael]

And that´s exactly why I want it out,
or atleast so,
that only members of the Forum could vote for the mark of rating /-

Casual "no play" voters wouldn´t bother registering /-

And thus,
Problem would be solved /-

[LeperMessiah]

Check out the most user opinions/comments on www.megagames.com

I agree with The Game Wizzard :)

[Eagle of Fire]

I also beleive that the forum is already doing it's part on what you are asking. How often to you read "This game is awesome! The best of all!" in the game discussion forum?

Pretty much as often than cries for help. :)

[Wael]

Eh,
it´s Wael...

But naturally you agree with me,
For I am right for once,
(has to be the only one so far...) /-

/To everyone else/
Sounded self-pretendeus?
Well Sue Me /-

[LeperMessiah]

Originally posted by Wael@Jan 12 2005, 08:17 PM
Eh,
it´s Wael...
Err, I know..
Just tried to be a little friendly.. um, Wael.
(like calling Neo as "The One")
Sorry if I did wrong :unsure:

[Wael]

You didn´t /-

A bad day,
feeling a bit annoyed of everything /-

You´re new?
Hope you´ll enjoy your stay for long /-

[Kosta]

Yes, I agree with Wael. An extra comment box would be completely unnecessary. I don't see what the point of the forum game discussion would be in that case. And also, such a comment box is a lure for the "F***k this gamesux!!!1 cant run!" and similar comments.... which wouldn't contribute to the page in any way

[LeperMessiah]

Originally posted by Wael@Jan 12 2005, 08:30 PM
You didn´t /-

A bad day,
feeling a bit annoyed of everything /-

You´re new?
Hope you´ll enjoy your stay for long /-
I see.. Well I understand.

Yes I'm new :unsure: and I enjoy my stay here, thank you :ph34r:

:)

[Unknown Hero]

"Discuss this game" from shout box should just do the trick! :ok:
I think that's "User comments" topic.

[Wael]

Are you saying that in the game review page,
There should be a shoutbox for such comments?

If so,
No,
It wouldn´t propably fit the site either,
Stupid comments in a smaller space would be stupid comments nevertheless,
And wouldn´t fit the "clean & smart interface" of Abandonia /-

And besides,
are the shoutboxes even free?

[Havell]

Yep. (http://www.shoutbox.com)

[Yamcha]

if u have a user name and password <_<

[wormpaul]

When it cames here i think it would be truly fine..

Sometimes i just get so pissed by the reviewers..they gave a totally wrong indication of the game in my opinion...but that will be also working the other way..

So when really needed...just say all you want on the forum about the game :ok:

EDIT: Can we make a box for a people who wanna say something useful about the review...so we got 1 people giving comments about the game... :angel:

[goblins]

a area seperate from the forum where forum members can contribute their own reviews versus general discussion on the game. ?

You would be able to contribute a review but it would have to be screened by admin before going up

[wormpaul]

Not a total new review...just a few comments on parts of the review..

I know it`s difficult but it can work great as long as people it does serious!! :whistle:

[Unknown Hero]

Originally posted by Wael@Jan 12 2005, 09:49 PM
Are you saying that in the game review page,
There should be a shoutbox for such comments?

If so,
No,
It wouldn´t propably fit the site either,
Stupid comments in a smaller space would be stupid comments nevertheless,
And wouldn´t fit the "clean & smart interface" of Abandonia /-

And besides,
are the shoutboxes even free?
I actually wanted to write a response to Omuletzu (that I'm disagreeing). Instead of extras I wrote shout box! :tomato: :tomato:
I guess I was too tired.

[Omuletzu]

Okay i guess it's a no go... closed :bye: