Doom Vs Doom 3

[verek_22]

Hi.

I thought it'd be fun to ask: Do you prefer the classic Doom, or the new Doom 3?

I vote for the classic Doom. But what do you think? :w00t:

Edit: Ahh, I forgot to add a reject option on the questions.

[The Fifth Horseman]

How would you like me to modify the poll options?

[verek_22]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(the_fifth_horseman @ May 9 2007, 11:49 AM) 289703</div>
How would you like me to modify the poll options?
[/b]

Thanks! Its supposed to look like this:


The classic Doom

Doom 1
Doom 2
Don't like classic Dooms

Doom 3

Doom 3
Doom 3 ROE Expansion pack
Don't like new Dooms

[The Fifth Horseman]

:ok: Is done.

[TheChosen]

Havent played any of the new Doom's yet (altought I have played the board game, but thats totally different). However, If I had to choose, I would play originals.

[troop18546]

Doom3

[Sathanas]

Doom2.

[_r.u.s.s.]

good choise, lord of darkness
it s something like original doom but with more weapons and better maps. well, but one thing which i missed in doom 2 from the first one was that cool map of the planet after each mission. its not much difference, but still gives you impression of 'dominating the planet' so you could get in to the story line better ..and it doom 2 it seemed to be pretty random sometimes

[Scatty]

Of all the Doom games I liked Ultimate Doom (4 episodes) and all parts of Doom II the most. Especially TNT - Evilution had great maps that I loved to visit again and again. Didn't play Doom 3 though, and I guess I won't either. Too bad I can choose only Doom I or II, so I chose Doom II.

[chainsoar]

Anyone remember my thread about how scary video games were a dead race?

Doom 3 proved me wrong. That game freaked the living christ out of me.

[ianfreddie07]

Doom2. The Icon of Sin is one of the best original bosses. I love nostalgia :wub:
I'll make that Revenant dance the chaingun cha-cha. :rifle: :monkey_dance:

[JoeBlack]

The original Dooms at that time gave this feeling of being in a new world. The step to the third dimension was done and it looked and felt just perfect.

Although being hungry for CPU cycles (I remember having played it on a 486/24 first, where you had to make the screen smaller to get smooth animations, just like "lowering the details" today) like Doom 3 and other current FPS are now with today's CPUs, it was just different. Not the gameplay... Doom 3 did a really good job transferring the nightmarish and oppressive feeling of the original, however, when it was released, it was one of many FPS I already have seen yet. Not the same feeling as with the originals. Strange enough, when playing them now, I still don't have this feeling any more... they just look... well... dated.

Looks like this feeling is gone foverer... :crybaby: at least until something really new will come up

[Nick]

Doom 3 is s**t. Apart from graphics, nothing interest. I had to always walk with spotlight, because it is damn dark there. I liked Doomsday, windows module, which can handle Hexen, Heretic and Dooms with OpenGL and 3D models.

[Carcaroth]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(chainsoar @ May 14 2007, 07:49 AM) 290187</div>
Anyone remember my thread about how scary video games were a dead race?

Doom 3 proved me wrong. That game freaked the living christ out of me.
[/b]

This happened here too, my friend. Nothing to be ashamed of. Doom 3 reached a new level in putting fear in who is playing. And I saw someone complaining about having to use the spotlight all the time cause it was dark and I say: Isn't it genious? The game is supposed to scare you, not to show you where the items are. And it sure did it. With me, at least. Thumbs up for Doom 3. :kosta:

[Nick]

Oh yeah. :)

That's also why this game sucks. Damn heart-attack generator. :) :angry:
Monsters from the dark and behind.

[chainsoar]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Carcaroth @ May 16 2007, 02:13 PM) 290494</div> I saw someone complaining about having to use the spotlight all the time cause it was dark and I say: Isn't it genious? The game is supposed to scare you, not to show you where the items are. And it sure did it. With me, at least. Thumbs up for Doom 3. :kosta: [/b]



I thought that too. The poor light just adds to the atmosphere. Monsters popping out of the shadows always shocks the crap out of me. I saw someone a few posts up use the phrase "oppressive". I can't think of a better word to describe the atmosphere of Doom 3. Those zombies...jesus.

[Subach]

i prefer doom 2 and doom 3 for the pc but i have the doom 3 and doom 3 roe for xbox too; roe for the pc is more heavy graphically btw im new here :)

[_r.u.s.s.]

wellcome brother :cheers:

[Subach]

ty :) congratulations for your 1000th post :D

[gufu1992]

Doom 2 for intense multi-player

[Sathanas]

Yep, used to coop doom2 with a friend back in the days. Was fun!

[Puggy123]

Doom 3 is a just a big seizure generator.
Classic.

[TheGiantMidgit]

Gotta go with the classic here. Still play it constantly. Doom 3 was great for that first run through, absolutely terrifying, but stagnates in the face of the arcade goodness that is the original Doom.

[faeornran]

Once you realize that you're fighting completely fictional characters on a video game with the gamma settings pushed up higher with some training gameplay while on god mode, you kind of get over it after a while.

:)

[TheGiantMidgit]

Suspension of disbelief bud. Also copious amounts of alcohol and a darkened room in the middle of the night.

[Burger Meister]

Didn't like doom 3 that much

loved doom 1, I grew up on that game... so it's teh ultimate. I do like doom 2 also, but doom 1 just has soo many memories on it!

[Eva02Soul]

Doom 2... Carving a roomful of pinkies up with a chainsaw was marvellous

[keremix]

i like them both

[Scarface]

I got Doom 3 like 4 weeks ago, but I haven't played it yet (my spare time is not that much as it used to be <_< ) . Anyway I think Doom will be the winner because of the memories it brings back.

[catfishingharry]

the classic DOOM, that was my first real computer love!! that game sold me on getting my own computer back then!!! i still like hexen, and now i have my son, 4 1/2 yrs old hooked on HERETIC2 awesome graphics!!

[guesst]

Before looking at the votes, I was almost ashamed to vote II. At first I didn't like it, it didn't add anything to the game, it just felt like an expansion pack, no technical progression at all. But once I was playing it I realized it was a reaaly good expansion pack.

[12turtle12]

I know I'm kind of jumping in here, but it was a really stupid idea to not be able to hold the flashlight w/
at least some of the guns. Couldn't he find any duct tape to strap it to the shotgun? How 'bout holding it like
a police officer when he had his handgun out? Is that impossible? No. Doom 2. At least they didn't give you the option...but the new expansion was EXCELLENT, so maybe I'll vote for that.

[Pipster]

Well, considering I hate scary games, and I found DOOM to be rather funny, I much prefer the classics.

[mdeba]

Old Dooms:

I voted for Doom 1, because Doom 2 had a bunch of frustrating levels in the middle (starting around level 15 or so). Too many monsters on tall buildings that you couldn't shoot at. Apparently they had a different level designer for that section.

New Dooms:

I voted for the expansion because there was a bit of stuffing around before killing anything substantial in the original.

[kbutcher5]

I think doom3 sucks behind, and i think the doom movie were better than doom3 :P
But doom and doom 2 has the cult status they deserve, the movie is a scham to these classics and i love them, i still play em from time to time, and they should be upthere with starcraft and opther games which deserve to be honorated for their genious gameplay :)

[Morrin]

Nah, I prefer first quake more than any of these. Sure doom and doom 2 were classics when they came out but I don't like them that much anymore. Doom 3 was quite frustrating, but the graphics were awesome. Expansion was much better, no wonder because it wasn't made by ID. :)

[Sezzubus]

Original Doom is still one of my fave games of all time! The joy is hardley lessened!

Never really got into new dooms too much, but in saying so, never really gave them much change with all my "pure doom" theories!!

I have doom on my mobile tho...

That kinda rocks some :ok:

[acetaminophen]

I voted for Doom2 :) My parents probably still hate it. I used to skip classes to play! eheheh :D

[JJXB]

i have doom 3:ROE on xbox and it's not that impressive really. i've put more time into quake 4 on the 360 in that respect. In reference to the old dooms, i prefer doom II. but whichever one i play, their a lot of fun on the move (if you have a psp that's homebrew capable and the wad's, get the psp port :D)

[pete]

Original Dooms (1 and 2). Also, you can play doom in the iPOD (i think its the ipod), that rocks.

[dosraider]

Can't vote :/
Problem is that my favorite Doom isn't in the poll.
It ain't Doom neither Doom3.
It's the mixture of both.

DOOM 3 - Classic Doom 3 v1.1 FINAL
Doom (1) maps ported to Doom3.

You get Doom gameplay on Doom3 graphics.
And of course multiplayer included. Yéééééééhaw.

The mod is of course freeware, those who have Doom3 really should try this out.
(You need the full Doom3 1.3 to be able to use that mod.)

[jg007]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(dosraider @ Aug 27 2007, 09:45 AM) 307003</div>
really should try this out.
(You need the full Doom3 1.3 to be able to use that mod.)
[/b]

damn, I swapped doom 3 for quake so I haven't got it anymore otherwise I would have checked that out :(,

[chainsoar]

I appreciate that this is an old-school gaming community - and I personally voted Doom 2 because it's just one of my favourite games ever - but I wish people would stop attacking Doom 3 so much. It's a good game, and I can give you one reason it deserves to be a part of the Doom franchise - it's scary as hell sometimes. Remember how when you were playing Doom 2 you'd be wandering along, then come around a corner and - ARGH zombie in the face! Doom 3 has plenty of that, I jumped a lot while playing it.

[Morrin]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(dosraider @ Aug 27 2007, 08:45 AM) 307003</div>
Can't vote :/
Problem is that my favorite Doom isn't in the poll.
It ain't Doom neither Doom3.
It's the mixture of both.

DOOM 3 - Classic Doom 3 v1.1 FINAL
Doom (1) maps ported to Doom3.

You get Doom gameplay on Doom3 graphics.
And of course multiplayer included. Yéééééééhaw.

The mod is of course freeware, those who have Doom3 really should try this out.
(You need the full Doom3 1.3 to be able to use that mod.)
[/b]

Hey, thanks a lot for the tip! I have to try that out

[Matt Samyel]

Classic Doom, because i have slow computer

[Morrin]

Now that I said I don't like doom(s) that much anymore, I suddenly do. :D I mean, started 'em up after long time and having fun wit dem

[Dogwolf]

Hmmm gotta go with the original....

[thebes]

The first Doom because it was new and scared the crap out of me. My shoulder muscles used to be sore from tensing up so much. Loved the face in it too! On of my old fav's. :kosta: